Dave has lots of luck with the ladies. The ladies aren't so lucky.
| Name | Role |
|---|---|
| Alison Becker | Michelle |
| Thomas Middleditch | Dave |
| Jessie Cantrell | |
| Ilana Glazer | Self |
| Nick Kocher | |
| Jamie Lee | |
| Brian McElhaney | |
| Megan Neuringer | |
| Mike O'Gorman | |
| Josh Ruben | |
| Seaton Smith | |
| Cecily Strong | Self |
| Sasheer Zamata | |
| Henry Zebrowski |