Plot
In Iowa, a girl in foster care discovers her talent for butter carving and finds herself pitted against an ambitious local woman in their town's annual contest.
Cast
| Name | Role |
|---|---|
| Jennifer Garner | Laura Pickler |
| Ty Burrell | Bob Pickler |
| Garrett Schenck | Orval Flanagan |
| Kristen Schaal | Carol Ann Stevenson |
| Jason Yudoff | Announcer |
| Phyllis Smith | Nancy |
| Judy Leavell | Helen Flanagan |
| Joe Chrest | Butter Fan |
| Deana Ricks | Butter Fan's Wife |
| Yara Shahidi | Destiny |
| Kelly Tippens | Mrs. Moore |
| Dodie Brown | June Carmichael |
| Jeanne Evans | Mrs. Gunderson |
| Cindy Creekmore | Danielle Mattingly |
| Christine Scheller | Transitional Home Worker |
| Alicia Silverstone | Jill |
| Rob Corddry | Ethan |
| Ashley Greene | Kaitlen Pickler |
| Olivia Wilde | Brooke |
| Brett Hill | Hayden |
| Corena Chase | Mrs. Schram |
| Hugh Jackman | Boyd Bolton |
| Mark Oliver | Martin Caswell |
| Andrew Daly | Radio Announcer |
| Pruitt Taylor Vince | Ned Eaton |
| Michael C. 'Mike' Allen | Corporate Employee |
| Jennifer Benton | Car Buyer |
| Charlotte Biggs | State Fair Patron |
| Gavin Casalegno | Art Class Student |
| Heather Cates | Laura's Fan |
| Pearce Chadwick | Webelo |
| Cassie Tobin Chappell | Extra |
| Tracy Chappell | Extra |
| JoAnn Cole | Self |
| Marian Drey | State Fair Patron |
| Laine Dubroc | Band Geek |
| Ted Ferguson | The Minister |
| Jed Fox | Fair Attendee |
| Jude Gavi | Fair Goer |
| Kevin A. Green | State Fair Goer |
| Rachel Greene | Miss Dairy - Betsy Lou Holt |
| Lindsey Hallen | Transitional Home School Kid |
| RJ Hanson | Technician |
| Juanita Harrison | Car Shopper |
| Everett Hibner | Webelo Boy Scout |
| Jb Jaura | Fair Goer |
| Herb Johnston | Iowa Farmer |
| R. Todd Jones | State Fair Patron |
| Avery Kelley | Art Class Kid |
| Austin Kennedy | Reporter |
| Michael Kober | Tony the Car Salesman |
| Ryne Little | Transitional Home Kid |
| Caleb Long | Fair Goer |
| Shelli McCollister-Fox | Fair Attendee |
| Aidan McFarland | Red Head Boy |
| Eric Kelly McFarland | State Fair Parent |
| Robin McGee | Clerk |
| Daniel Mignault | Art Class Kid |
| Austin William Morgan | Tv Reporter |
| Saffton Reed Neuman | Teen visiting Butter exhibits / Obsessed fan at rally / Pre-rally stage crew |
| Daniel Nix | Fair Attendee |
| Jonathan O'Rear | Fair Person / Student |
| James Paul | Museum Spectator |
| Cynthia Riser | Parishioner |
| Shelby Schneider | School Girl at the Fair |
| Alice Searcy | Fair Goer |
| Keri Shahidi | Biological Mother |
| Molly Jane Sullivan | Art Class Kid |
| Lanie Taylor | Art Class Kid |
| Jody Thompson | Random Diner |
| David Lee Valle | Police Officer |
| Chevy White | Butter Fan |